Flagstick In or Out When Putting? What the Rules and Research Say
You have a putt you’d really like to make, and someone asks, “Flag in or out?” It sounds like a small decision. Then you remember the putt that bounced off the pin last week, or the one it stopped from racing past.
Both choices are allowed. The more useful question is what you expect the flagstick to do for this particular putt. It can help in some collisions and hurt in others, so there isn’t an honest promise that leaving it in, or taking it out, will make every golfer hole more putts.
Our practical starting point: use the view that lets you settle over the ball comfortably, and keep your normal approach to pace. If you like a clear cup, take the flag out. If you prefer seeing the pin, leave it in. Don’t hit the putt harder because you expect the flagstick to rescue it.
What do the rules allow?
Under Rule 13.2, you may leave the flagstick in, remove it, or have someone attend it. Decide before your stroke. A ball hitting a flagstick you chose to leave in normally carries no penalty.
You may center the flagstick before putting, but must not deliberately position it off-center to gain an advantage. Once the ball is moving, don’t move or remove the flagstick to influence where it finishes.
Having someone attend the flagstick means they show you the hole’s position and then remove it during or after the stroke. Agree on that arrangement before you putt.
What does the research actually tell us?
In a 2020 CHANCE paper, statistician Christopher Bilder analyzed a controlled ramp experiment that varied ball speed and entry line. Slow arrivals showed no clear advantage either way. At medium speed, removing the flagstick helped off-center entries. At high speed, leaving it in helped direct, central hits.
Bilder recommended taking it out, reasoning that golfers were more likely to arrive at medium speed than at the high speeds where a central collision helped. That recommendation deserves attention. It was still based on controlled ball arrivals, rather than golfers completing rounds with both approaches.
The practical lesson is that “the pin saved my putt” and “the pin knocked my putt out” can both be true. Where the ball meets the stick, and how fast it gets there, matter. A demonstration of one collision cannot establish which choice saves you strokes over a season.
What about confidence and the view of the hole?
A University of Akron honors project studied live putting by golfers with handicaps of four or better. At some tested distances, golfers who preferred the flagstick out finished closer to the hole with it removed. Those who preferred it in showed no significant difference. The author cautioned against firm conclusions.
That’s an interesting clue about preference, not proof that confidence overrides everything else. The project measured finishing distance, so it should not be presented as a finding that everyone holes more putts with their preferred option.
For your own game, pay attention to what happens over the ball. Does the flag give you a useful target, or do you keep staring at the narrow space beside it? You don’t need to copy another golfer’s choice if it makes your own routine uncomfortable.
How to decide on the putt in front of you
A short putt you expect to make
If the flagstick makes the cup feel crowded, take it out. There’s little value in standing over a three-footer while arguing with yourself about the pin.
If you like it in, keep the same deliberate routine you would use with an empty cup. Read the putt, choose your start line, and commit to your pace. Don’t turn a short putt into a jab at the flagstick.
A long putt where the flag helps you see the target
Leaving it in can be a convenient choice when you want a visible reference from farther away. Treat that as a preference you can try, rather than a guaranteed improvement in distance judgment.
Before you address the ball, look at the whole putt. Where does it climb or fall? Where do you want it to start? The pin tells you where the hole is; it doesn’t choose the route or the pace for you.
A quick downhill putt
This is where it’s tempting to think of the flagstick as insurance. Resist the urge to change your stroke around that hope. Your first job is still to judge how gently the ball needs to start.
Choose in or out before stepping into the putt, then put your attention back on speed. If you find yourself thinking “the pin will stop it,” step away and choose the pace you actually want.
A distracting flag or an awkward-looking stick
If a flapping flag or the way the stick looks is pulling your attention away from the putt, removing it is a simple option. You don’t need to diagnose the flagstick’s material or flexibility while your group waits.
The aim is a decision you can make and then leave alone. Avoid adding an inspection ritual to every green.
Try both before making a permanent rule
If you’re genuinely undecided, use a few minutes on the practice green before a round. This is a way to find a comfortable routine, not a home experiment that proves one method is statistically better.
Start with a short putt and alternate between flagstick in and out. Use the same ball and starting spot, and give each option the same number of attempts. Alternate which option goes first so one doesn’t always get the benefit of your latest read.
Then try a longer putt and a gentle downhill putt. Notice whether you can settle into your setup, start the ball where you intend, and leave a manageable next putt. Record makes and finishing distances if you like, but don’t let one lucky bounce decide everything.
Repeat on another day before drawing a strong conclusion. If neither choice feels different, choose the convenient option and spend the rest of your practice time on the parts of putting you can work on directly.
Keep the decision easy for your group
A quick “I’d like it out, please” before your turn is usually enough. Try to settle the question while others are preparing, rather than waiting until you are ready to strike the ball.
If you remove the flagstick, put it somewhere it won’t distract anyone or interfere with play. Handle it carefully and retrieve your ball without scraping the edge of the hole. This should be a small part of the routine, not a discussion that starts again on every green.
Conclusion: choose, commit, and putt
You don’t need a rigid flagstick policy to be a thoughtful putter. Start with the view you prefer, try the alternative if you’re curious, and make your choice before you settle over the ball.
Then get back to the putt itself. Pick your line and pace, make your stroke, and resist rewriting your whole approach because of one bounce.
Frequently asked questions
Is a ball resting against the flagstick holed?
If any part of the ball is in the hole below the putting-green surface, it is holed. If no part is below that surface, it is not. If removing the flagstick then moves that unholed ball, even into the hole, replace it on the lip without penalty.
Should I always leave the flagstick in for downhill putts?
We wouldn’t make that an automatic rule. Decide which view you prefer and keep your attention on the pace the slope requires. Leaving it in should never be your reason to hit a downhill putt more firmly.
Should I copy what professional golfers do?
Use their routines as ideas to try. A choice that looks comfortable for someone on television may feel distracting to you. Test both views during practice and keep the decision simple on the course.
What if I’m putting from the fringe?
First decide whether putting is the right shot for the lie and the grass between you and the green. Our guide to putting versus chipping from the fringe walks through that decision. Once you’ve chosen the shot, decide how you want the target to look.
