Putter Comparisons

Milled Putters vs. Insert Putters: Which One is Best for Your Game?

By puttmasterPublished 3 min read

Milled Putters vs. Insert Putters: Which One is Right for Your Game?

Choosing the right putter can significantly impact your feel, distance control, and consistency on the greens. One of the key differences among putters is whether they have a milled face or an insert face.

Key Differences: Milled vs. Insert Putters

Feature
 Milled Putters
 Insert Putters
Face Material
 Solid block of metal (steel, aluminum, or copper)
 Soft insert (polymer, aluminum, or composite)
Feel
 Firm, solid feedback
 Soft, muted impact
Sound
 Metallic “click”
 Softer, duller sound
Roll Quality
 Consistent, direct roll
 Insert tech can help reduce skidding
Who Prefers It?
 Players who like feedback & control
 Players who like a softer feel
Ball Type
 Works best with soft golf balls
 Works best with firm golf balls

Milled Putters: The Precision Choice

A milled putter is crafted from a single block of metal (usually stainless steel or carbon steel), ensuring precision and consistency. The milling process creates grooves or patterns on the face that help with roll and feel.

Pros of Milled Putters

  • Offers superior feedback for control and consistency.

  • More durable, as it has no inserts that can wear out.

  • Classic look, preferred by many professional golfers.

Cons of Milled Putters

  • Generally less forgiving on mishits compared to insert putters.

  • The firmer impact might not appeal to all golfers.

Popular Milled Putters

  1. Scotty Cameron Newport 2 – Known for precision and feel, used by Tiger Woods.

  2. PING PLD Anser – Milled for consistency and preferred by tour players.

  3. Bettinardi BB1 – Crafted in the USA, featuring fine milling patterns.

  4. Evnroll ER2 – Milled with a special groove design to enhance roll.

Insert Putters: The Softer Touch

Insert putters feature a soft insert in the face, often made from urethane, polymer, or composite materials. The purpose is to soften impact and create a more forgiving feel. Some inserts are designed to promote topspin and reduce skidding.

Pros of Insert Putters

  • Provides a softer feel at impact, ideal for firmer golf balls.

  • More forgiving on off-center hits.

  • Some inserts add extra roll consistency.

Cons of Insert Putters

  • Less feedback, which makes it harder to judge distance.

  • Inserts can wear out over time, affecting performance.

Popular Insert Putters

  1. Odyssey White Hot OG – Known for its soft feel and one of the most popular insert putters ever.

  2. TaylorMade Spider X – Features Pure Roll insert for better topspin.

  3. Odyssey Tri-Hot 5K – Combines steel and insert technology for added stability.

  4. Cobra King Vintage – Uses SIK aluminum insert for improved roll.

Performance Comparison: Feel, Forgiveness & Consistency

Here’s a comparison of key factors between milled and insert putters based on performance characteristics:

Performance Factor
 Milled Putters
 Insert Putters
Feel & Feedback
 Firm, direct feedback
 Soft, muted impact
Forgiveness
 Less forgiving on mishits
 More forgiving on mishits
Roll Quality
 Consistent, pure roll
 Improved topspin with inserts
Sound
 Crisp, metallic sound
 Duller, quieter sound
Durability
 Long-lasting, no inserts to wear out
 Inserts may wear over time

Which Putter is Right for You?

Choose a milled putter if:

  • You like precise feedback on your stroke.

  • You prefer a firmer feel and a crisper sound.

  • You want maximum durability with no inserts to wear out.

Choose an insert putter if:

  • You like a soft, muted feel at impact.

  • You want more forgiveness on mishits.

  • You play with firm golf balls and want to soften the feel.

Similar Posts