Putter Comparisons

TaylorMade Spider GT vs. Scotty Cameron Newport 2

By puttmasterPublished 5 min read

Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2 vs. TaylorMade Spider GT Putter: A Comprehensive Comparison

When it comes to choosing the right putter, golfers must consider various factors such as feel, alignment, forgiveness, and stroke type. Two of the most popular putters on the market in 2025 are the Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2 and the TaylorMade Spider GT.

While both are top-tier putters, they cater to different types of golfers due to their design, weighting, and overall performance characteristics.

This article provides a detailed comparison of these two putters, covering their manufacturer details, key features, benefits, and the type of golfer each putter is best suited for.

Manufacturer Information

Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2

  • Manufacturer: Scotty Cameron (a division of Titleist)

  • Founded by: Scotty Cameron, a renowned putter designer, partnered with Titleist in 1994

  • Known for: Precision-milled putters, used by many PGA Tour professionals

  • Brand Reputation: Premium craftsmanship, exceptional feel, and consistent quality

TaylorMade Spider GT

  • Manufacturer: TaylorMade Golf

  • Founded in: 1979

  • Known for: Innovative club designs, especially in metalwoods, irons, and putters

  • Brand Reputation: Cutting-edge technology, high-MOI putters, and enhanced forgiveness

While both brands have a strong reputation, Scotty Cameron is known for its precision and craftsmanship in blade putters, while TaylorMade is recognized for innovation, particularly in mallet putters with high-MOI technology.

Key Features and Benefits

Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2 (Blade Putter)

Design and Build

The Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2 is a classic blade putter with a sleek, minimalistic look. It is milled from a solid block of 303 stainless steel, providing a premium feel and a soft yet responsive impact. The putter features tungsten sole weights, which improve balance and stability while maintaining a traditional appearance.

Face Technology and Feel

This putter features dual-milled face technology, which enhances the roll and feedback upon impact. The face milling provides a consistent feel, making it easier for players to gauge distance control. Many golfers appreciate the soft yet solid sensation it provides, allowing for maximum feedback on each stroke.

Weighting and Balance

The Newport 2’s tungsten sole weights enhance overall balance, making the putter more stable throughout the stroke. The weight distribution ensures an optimal toe flow, meaning it suits golfers with an arc-style putting stroke.

Alignment and Stroke Type

Unlike mallet putters, the Newport 2 does not feature extensive alignment aids. It has a clean, traditional topline that appeals to golfers who prefer a simpler look. Due to its moderate toe hang, it is best suited for players with an arcing stroke rather than a straight-back, straight-through motion.

Who It’s Best For:

  • Golfers with consistent putting strokes who prefer traditional blade designs
  • Players who value precision and feel over forgiveness
  • Those who prefer minimal alignment aids and a clean aesthetic
  • Typically favored by low-handicap and professional players

TaylorMade Spider GT (Mallet Putter)

Design and Build

The TaylorMade Spider GT is a high-MOI mallet putter, designed to maximize stability and forgiveness. It features a lightweight aluminum top plate, which reduces unnecessary weight, and steel side wings, which help distribute weight to the perimeter. This high-MOI design prevents twisting on off-center hits, making the putter more forgiving.

Face Technology and Feel

The Spider GT features Pure Roll² insert technology, which enhances forward roll and reduces skidding. The insert provides a slightly softer feel than a milled face, ensuring consistency on longer putts. Players who prefer a softer touch will likely appreciate this feature.

Weighting and Balance

With its perimeter-weighted design, the Spider GT is one of the most stable putters on the market. The tungsten and steel weighting system ensures that even on off-center strikes, the putter face remains square, leading to more consistent results. This makes it ideal for golfers who struggle with mis-hits.

Alignment and Stroke Type

The Spider GT offers large alignment aids on the topline, making it easier to line up putts accurately. Unlike blade putters, the Spider GT is face-balanced, making it best suited for straight-back, straight-through strokes.

Who It’s Best For:

  • Golfers who need more forgiveness on off-center strikes
  • Players who benefit from large alignment aids
  • Those who prefer a mallet putter with high stability
  • Typically favored by mid- to high-handicap golfers, but also used by some tour professionals for its forgiveness and stability

Which Putter Should You Choose?

Choose the Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2 If You:

✅ Prefer a traditional blade putter with a classic design
✅ Have an arcing stroke that benefits from moderate toe hang
✅ Value precision, feel, and feedback over forgiveness
✅ Are a low-handicap golfer looking for maximum control

Choose the TaylorMade Spider GT If You:

✅ Prefer a mallet putter with a modern, high-MOI design
✅ Have a straight-back, straight-through stroke
✅ Need forgiveness and stability on off-center hits
✅ Want alignment aids to help square the putter face
✅ Are a mid- to high-handicap golfer looking for more consistency

Final Thoughts

Both the Scotty Cameron Super Select Newport 2 and the TaylorMade Spider GT are excellent putters, but they serve different purposes based on a golfer’s stroke type, skill level, and personal preference.

  • If you are an experienced player with a refined stroke looking for maximum feedback and feel, the Scotty Cameron Newport 2 is the better choice.
  • If you are a golfer who struggles with consistency and needs a more forgiving putter, the TaylorMade Spider GT is the way to go.

Ultimately, the best putter is the one that suits your stroke and gives you confidence on the greens. Testing both putters before making a decision can help ensure that you select the right one for your game.

Pro Tip: When choosing a putter, consider getting a professional fitting. A proper putter fitting will ensure that you have the right loft, lie angle, and length for your stroke, leading to improved performance on the greens.

Similar Posts